Published: 2014-05-16 12:50:10 by Daniele Ricci

Many users have been wondering about security in Kontalk. In this post I'll consider the security concerns I faced and I'm still facing during the development of Kontalk.

Phone numbers

The biggest security implication is phone numbers. Hiding phone numbers to server administrators and to other users is very difficult since they are used as mean of identification. Kontalk uses hashes of the phone numbers in the user ID (something like, which is the SHA-1 hash of +15555245554).
Using decent hardware, by knowing just the country code, you can calculate all of the hash space and find the original value in a relatively short time. It's an easy task to carry out, but you'll have to spend time on that, meaning you have a target.
The hard part comes when the Kontalk devteam is not involved in server administration: despite we have very strong values and we do not give our data to others (of course we are tied to jurisdiction), other server administrators might. That's why we decided to create some sort of democratic network with an internal voting system, used to allow new servers and ban rogue ones. This system is not yet in place (we are still in alpha), but it will be ready at the right time. Further details will follow soon.

SMS provider

Another concern for phone numbers is using a 3rd party SMS provider to verify the numbers. In our case, Nexmo.
Of course it's a company and they have their privacy policy, but the problem is a Kontalk server must know the real phone number to send the verification SMS in the first place, meaning our Nexmo account has a record of all phone numbers that have registered or have tried to register to Kontalk. We really can't do nothing about it. Although we access Nexmo logs only when a user has a problem during registration, in fact we do have the phone numbers of all of our users.

Encryption: end-to-end without OTR

Encryption is another very important security concern. The older 2.2 versions had a weak encryption method which is being replaced by OpenPGP encryption in version 3.0. This new method will do a simple public key encryption using OpenPGP standards. More features such as perfect forward secrecy and deniable encryption will be addressed with a future version having an OTR-like approach.

Trusting server administrators

Last but not least, there is a concern about server administrators. Kontalk is designed to be a community network, meaning that volounteers can rent servers and make them available as Kontalk nodes. Those nodes will have access to all presence data and (unencrypted) messages passing through the server.
A server can prevent login attempts from users registered from another server though: it checks if the server public key is signed by the server that is authenticating the user in that moment. This is the way a server shows "trust" in one another. If anything happens, a revocation of the signature and that server is no longer trusted.
Anyway this doesn't prevent a rogue server from creating forged identities or fake accounts. There are mechanisms to protect users against that, but only when such abuses are discovered — that's because if an abuse is sporadic, it's hard to uncover it.

Still, there's no formal agreement between servers. They all count on mutual trust and spoken deals. This matter will be addressed when Kontalk will grow enough to justify the creation of a nonprofit organization, with an organized team and a more defined path to follow.

Published: 2012-11-21 19:46:50 by Daniele Ricci

Today someone told me:

The admins of the server I use don't allow the installation of PHP due to the numerous and for years not decreasing number of security problems with the language itself and the majority of applications using it

That really doesn't surprise me: I know PHP can be a real pain when it comes to using some monster apps such as Wordpress, Drupal, Joomla, and so on. Actually I don't use them, but I was curious, so I googled:

php security issues

OMG! I knew PHP wasn't safe, but as long as you write your application in a safe way and correctly setup your hosting, you should be ok. At least I like to believe I should be ok. By the way, this checklist is very interesting:

This blogging platform is written in PHP...... Should I get worried?